3.7 KiB
#region DashboardScenarioModel.ValidationReport [C:3] [TYPE ADR] [SEMANTICS validation,gate,scenario] @defgroup Validation Pre-implementation validation gate for the Dashboard Scenario Model (compiler-layer scope).
Status: VALID (compiler-layer scope) — generated 2026-08-11
Date: 2026-08-11 (generated from current artifacts by reconcile_contracts.py 036-047)
Feature: 038 Dashboard Scenario Model
Scope: Compiler/IR layer ONLY. Runtime capture/VLM/disposition/evidence is owned by 044.
History: Prior versions of this file self-contradicted (claimed PASS covering full implementation while runtime T057–T059 were open, and asserted YAML validity that the parser rejected). This revision is regenerated from the machine-readable artifacts and is compiler-scope only.
Machine-Contract Verification (2026-08-11)
| Check | Result |
|---|---|
OpenAPI YAML parse (contracts/openapi.yaml) |
✅ parses (fix: quoted flow-scalar with : on disposition description) |
| OpenAPI semantic paths + identity (scenario_key/content_hash, runtime endpoints deprecated) | ✅ verified |
JSON Schema parse (dashboard-test-scenario.schema.json) |
✅ valid JSON |
JSON Schema Verification Program (SqlEvidenceSpec, Transform/Comparison/AgentEvaluation specs) |
✅ required canonical content, included in content hash contract |
| ParameterDefinition runtime-state exclusion | ✅ no value or status; 044 owns ParameterBinding |
| Versioned ActionRegistry | ✅ current valid fixture actions registered; unknown runtime action blocked |
| Fixtures validate against JSON Schema | ✅ 6/6 (fixtures/api/*.json), after migration to canonical identity |
| Fixture fingerprint lengths (input_fingerprints.* 64-hex) | ✅ fixed (was 66-char parameters) |
| 044 runtime boundary | ✅ typed StepOutcome/AgentEvaluation events; no runtime SQL mutation request surface |
Compiler-Layer Gate Decision
Verdict: ✅ PASS (compiler/IR scope) — 038 compiler/validator/resolver/canonicalizer + Verification Program schema/action registry + fixtures are internally consistent and machine-validated.
NOT a full-feature PASS: execution (real VLM submit, real capture, evidence owner_type=scenario_run, HumanCheckpoint) is owned by 044 and gated there. Do not read this as authorizing 044 runtime implementation.
Blocking Findings
None for the compiler-layer scope. The prior "runtime closure" findings are relocated to 044 (they are not 038 responsibilities).
Artifact Completeness (actual tree)
| Artifact | Status |
|---|---|
| spec.md, plan.md, research.md, data-model.md, tasks.md, traceability.md, quickstart.md, ux_reference.md | ✅ |
| checklists/requirements.md | ✅ |
| contracts/modules.md, contracts/openapi.yaml, contracts/verification-program.md, contracts/action-registry.yaml | ✅ |
| contracts/dashboard-test-scenario.schema.json, contracts/capture-profile.schema.json | ✅ |
| contracts/ux/{scenario-graph-ux,alternatives,decisions,api-ux}.md | ✅ |
| contracts/openapi-traceability.md | ✅ |
| prototype/index.html + manifest.md | ✅ |
| checklist-catalog.md | ✅ |
| fixtures/api/*.json (6) | ✅ validated |
Warning
- W03: Frontend rendering is DTO-only in 038; 039 owns the create UI, 045 owns run monitor. Confirm downstream UI tasks exist (already in 039/045).
- Runtime endpoints in
contracts/openapi.yamlaredeprecated(moved to 044); OpenAPI-traceability must reflect this when regenerated.
Generation rule
This report is generated from the current package gate rather than a manually maintained digest table. Any contract change requires rerunning backend/.venv/bin/python reconcile_contracts.py 036-047; a non-zero result invalidates this verdict.
#endregion DashboardScenarioModel.ValidationReport